The Horse Nobody Wanted
Warning: This will not be a feel-good post. You may want to skip it if you're having a bad day already.
Left at an livestock auction yard to be sold, this blind horse got no bids--not even from the buyers there to acquire horses by the pound.See the horse in the accompanying photo? You can see him, but he could never see you. That's because he's blind--as blind as they come. Take a close look at those feet. They not only haven't been trimmed by man in, oh, I'd say a couple of years, but also haven't even been worn down by movement of the horse himself. Seems pretty obvious to me that this pathetic animal had stood in one place, eating whatever's been put in front of him, for a considerably long time.
I took this picture of him a few days ago, when he turned up at our area livestock market for its monthly horse sale. This is the kind of sale that could be nicknamed The Cleaners, because for the most part, it's where people bring horses they've decided to be rid of. Most are sold loose, like cattle, and their weight flashes on a tote board as they walk across the sale ring's floor-scale. Depending on their size and degree of flesh, maybe on some other quality that allows them to find a new owner "out in the country," they bring $35, $85, $150, $275, $350 a head.
A good 90 percent of the horses sold at an auction like this will be swept into three or four kill-buyers' holding pens. The sellers know this. The crowd knows this. It's a livestock market, after all, where horses follow cattle, hogs, sheep and goats on the day's auction docket. A few folks are there looking for a cheap riding horse, maybe some old gelding suitable for the grandkids.
But for the most part, this is a meat market, part of agricultural commerce. No different than the ones my dad went to, four and five days a week, while earning a living as a sheep and cattle buyer, and from whence he fetched me the 2-year-old gelding that was the first horse I bought with my own money.
Back to the blind horse. When it finally got to be his turn to sell, he didn't elicit a single bid. Not even from the kill buyers. Not even for the auctioneer's final offer of $5. Not even from anyone who might have had the impulse to rescue him.
Biggest reason: His lack of sight made him nearly impossible to move. He wouldn't lead, and could barely be herded, even by multiple men. You had to wonder how the owner had even gotten him to the auction yard (but then again, probably wouldn't want to know). He never did step on the weight scale--he just pressed himself against the gate, refusing to step on the scale's shifting surface.
To a buyer with a load to fill and move on, toward Canada or Mexico, he was just a big liability. Not worth the trouble to bother with.
To someone feeling the pluck of heartstrings, he was a series of questions that couldn't be answered in the 30 seconds it took for him to be no-saled. How would you ever get him home? What would you DO with a blind horse? What would it cost to be the one taking the merciful step of just having him be put down? What would your husband say? (Add your own questions here.)
I saw the market owner after the sale. I asked him what happens when a consigned animal doesn't sell. "We'll call the owner and tell him to come get it," he replied. "Think they'll show up?" I asked. He shrugged. "Never know."
And to think...we still have those who maintain that there's no such thing as an unwanted horse.
Labels: blind horse


38 Comments:
That is such a sad story!
I don't think I could have stood there and watch him be no-saled and then hauled back to wherever he came from... I would have had to do SOMETHING. I don't know what... but I wouldn't have been able to walk away...
It makes me so sad, that people refuse to believe that there are unwanted horses out there and continue to breed willy nilly seemingly with no concern about the state of the horse market or what will happen to the foals once they are born...
That horse right there is a prime example... he didn't ask to be treated that way and his owner refused to take responsibilty and chose to toss him away...
On another note, that is why I am putting in writing what I want done with my animals should something happen to me... just so nothing like this could ever happen to them.
Too sad. Bless him, though, those feet could be fixed with a series of trims, I've seen worse. And he could be acclimated to new surroundings. It just takes time. So so sad!
Oh my heart breaks at this story. I acquired my app gelding before we went to the killers as an unbroke, starved ,beaten and abused 8yo who hated humans and thought of them as the enemy, He has since turned around completely and we show hunters and equitation among trail riding,m galloping hunter paces and others.
We have a blind mare at our barn and it's not as hard as people think. This mare is only 10 and blind due to some kids throwing acid in her eyes. She gets along well. She is turned out with an older companion. She knows the boundaries of her paddock and stall and is contantly within hearing distance of her friend. The other horse wears a bell on her halter as well so this mare can hear her. She moves fine and can be lunged. She is trusting of people and some never even know she is blind. There is hope for horses like this. They need trust and stability and can lead healthy and productive lives. I feel for thsi little appy in your blog and it's time like this I wish I had lots of money and a truck and trailer to sweep up this little angel.
Hey Julie,
Any way you can find out what's happening with this horse as of today?
I would take him and I can haul him. This kind of thing breaks my heart in pieces. He needs a seeing eye horse friend. I have several old horses that might work for that. And we can fix those feet right up.
If he's still there, I will find a way. Could we all come together and help this guy?
my email is michaelina2002@aol.com
Mikey--
I will email you about this matter.
Update:
The horse is still at the auction yard, unclaimed by its owner. The market's staff will allow a release to Mikey, if the horse is still there by tomorrow.
Stay tuned.
I checked which Mikey was "talking" and its the one I thought! If this horse is fortunate enough to get to Mikey's it is indeed watched by angels. He'll be the luckiest horse that was at that auction. :)
I'm not going to get into the whole selling horses for meat issue. HOWEVER if you have a horse such as this one, that not even a kill buyer would bid on... do the right thing and put it down humanely!
Keep us informed about the horse! I so hope he gets a new home with someone to give him the proper care he needs!
What a sad fate for a noble animal. God bless Mikey. If I lived in Idaho I would do the same. I have a mare that is just a lawn ornament. She has a soundness problem and if I were to try and sell her, she would only be bought by killers. I will never sell her. She will have a home as long as I live or she lives. She is a sweet horse and a fate like this horse is more than I could bear for her. If I ever have to, I will have her humanely put to sleep. Mikey is a Saint.
I posted this to the Fugly Blog at Mikey's request.
Hopefully there is something that can be done- quickly!- to get the poor guy out of there and out of danger.
He is a nice enough looking horse. I hope there is soon good news to report...
I too am not going to get into the slaughter issue, but I will say if you were trying to make a point that there is a need for it with this horse I think these readers point out it backfire on you?
Instead most of us saw it for what it was, a prime example of irresponsible horse ownership. In my opinion the horse owner should be sold for slaughter!
There are two or three people that have posted that have said they would take him...it doesn't matter if it was due to pitty or as I like to see it having mercy for him, they wanted to help him and therefore he is WANTED.
I had a blind horse in for training at one time. He was a looker a 5 years old QH, but had cataracts so bad he only saw faint shadows. He was a dream to ride in the safety of a flat arena with good dirt. He was light, responsive, sensitive, listened to you, and never offered to do silly stuff. By all accounts he would have made an awesome pleasure, western riding, horsemanship etc, things that he would perform in good dirt and needed only to trust and listen to the rider which he was very willing to do.
When I figured out he might be blind and called the vet to confirm, the owner also took him to the meat auction which I tired to talk him out of. This horse did very well with people and a companion horse in a large paddock. Who knows as sweet, gentle and willing as he was he might have been able to go to a handicapped riding program.
Even though at first glance this and other horses like him may seem to some an example for pro slaughter...to others he is still useful and deserves to live a decent life with someone that will love and take special care of him. And there are people who enjoy doing just that, it's a matter of getting the word out.
We're not all 'perfect" and I am going to point out the usefulness of yes even handicapped horses. "Gunner" the Paint world champion, NRHA futurity and derby winner is as deaf as they come.
God Bless you Mickey, and you too Julie for getting the word out. Now he will have a loving home.
Well I want to help this horse, and as it stands Shiloh Horse Rescue says they will open their doors to him, if no one else closer can or will.
But - I would rather see him rescued closer to home and not have to be hauled that far. So if anyone in WA or MT can get him, please, do so!
But if no one else can, I will go up there and haul him to Shiloh, where they have other blind horses and he will have the best of care.
Oh how I wished we could help! We are only 85 miles away, but we are not set up good enough to care for him safely!!! I am goin to call a friend who works at WSU vet hospital in the am...see if she has any ideas or people who could help!
I'm too far away, but Mikey let me know if you yourself have to go haul him and I can donate to your fuel fund.
Julie, I'm wondering why you would want to attend such an event as you described the 'cleaners'. Especially if you know that many of these horses go for meat rendering?
Mickey did you pick this horse up, did someone?
Working on it! Where it stands now is the horse is doing fine up there, no hurry to pick it up. I'm investigating a professional hauler who can maybe do it cheaper than me driving. The horse has a spot at Shiloh Horse Rescue as soon as it can be transported.
So it's coming together, but I am assured the horse is safe at the moment.
Please don't condem Julie for going to this sale. There are lots of people that go to them, me included. For one thing they are usually a social event where you can see people you haven't seen for a long time. Another reason is to keep up on the horse market and see what is happening. But the reason we go is we have found some great bargains at these sales. Six years ago I purchased a Hotrodder Jet Set mare that was hidden in a back stall at one of these sales. She is the most beautiful and best horse I have ever had. Every where i take her people try to purchase her. The owner just did not get along with her and did not want to pay a catalogue fee so she put her in this sale. Every once in awhile we have found a bargain at the sale. Yes, there are some really sad stories but one person can only save so many.
Good work Mike. I hope you get this horse saved. I had a friend that showed a blind horse for years. Some people's junk is another man's gold!
I don't think anyone can be condemned for reporting what happens at a sale. We don't like what happens, but we have no power to close the sales down. I used to attend the Pilot Point Sale in Texas and many time left feeling sick to my stomach. I bought quite a few for rehabbing, but you can't save them all. You can only hope to educate people by writing about what you see and hear while at such sales.
Tracy Meisenbach
www.trinityapp.com
http://thehorsediary.net/ (updated 9-6-2008)
This is certainly a sad story but it is one that needs to be told. It is an unfortunate truth of horse ownership that owners cannot always keep up their end of the bargain. I consider myself highly lucky to have my arthritic QH retired to a good friend's farm, but had it not been for her generosity in offering to keep him at cost, my family would have faced the similarly difficult choice of what to do with my aging and chronically lame equine buddy when I left home for grad school and my new horseless life. This post underscores the difficult decisions that owners face when keeping their animal is no longer a possibility.
Update - this horse will be picked up this Friday by me personally and transported to Shiloh Horse Rescue in NV. I will post another update as soon as the horse is safely at the rescue.
i have an appy that is blind also. she has been with 2 outher younger horses but they bully her. i have finally found her a home where she wont be pushed around. she is 17yrs. young and has such a big heart to please. her gradual blindness made it easy on her to comes to term with but leaving her with the other horses wasnt a good idea on my part. so this week she will have a place of her own so she doesnt get bullied anymore. i had to do what was best or her even tho i hate to see her go away. it is very sad to see a horse no one wants. luck was on our side tho and she will recieve a good home. thank u for letting people become aware of the tragedies of these horses with handicaps or problems. jeanie stone
C'mon, people who breed horses, get with the program and QUIT, yes quit breeding and adding to the problem. If it is your business then get out, find something else. And the rest of us, we can all DO something, I have six rescues right now, if everyone would DO something and save just one horse - think of the possibilities. And hopefully if the breeders quit breeding and people start helping, maybe we could get a good start on helping this problem.
GOD BLESS JULI & MIKEY FOR SAVING THIS BLIND HORSE...IF ONLY THEY COULD ALL BE SAVED FROM SLAUGHTER AND REHABBED IF NECESSARY. I WONDER IF JOHN LYONS COULD OFFER SOME ADVICE ON LEADING HIM AND LOADING HIM (MAYBE WITH A BUDDY HORSE), SINCE HE HAD ZIP, HIS APPY WHO WENT BLIND? SOMEONE AT YOUR MAGAZINE MAY KNOW HOW TO CONTACT HIM. DOES ANYONE ELSE HAVE ANY EXPERIENCE WITH THIS SITUATION? GOOD LUCK! KAREN & OSCAR
We all hate to see unwanted horses, but it is a fact. We all can't care for every horse for 30 years. Now the problem with putting a horse down is 'then what'. For many of us, there is no place to put a #1000 carcass. We can't bury it on our property, the landfill won't take them, the rendering plants have moved far away. So 'then what?'
God bless Mikey... and you can count on a contribution to the fuel fund from us too. i can't afford much but i will help as best i can...
Mikey's not expecting any contributions to her fuel fund. But Shiloh Horse Rescue, which has agreed to take him in, accepts sponsorships for horses. Mikey suggests looking into that. Easy to find Shiloh via Google.
I noticed that the blog on the topic of this precious blind horse stated this, "Seems pretty obvious to me that this pathetic animal had stood in one place, eating whatever's been put in front of him, for a considerably long time."
I would use a different choice of words than the word pathetic. This horse is beautiful and anything but pathetic. I know you mean well, and I commend you for doing everything you do to save these horses. I know Jill at Shiloh Horse Rescue and others such as Jo at the Angel Acres horse rescue in PA. They are awesome people who will go out of their way to help any animal. I'm so thankful that this horse is going to Shiloh, trust me, he's in excellent hands, they are very loving people. Also, I will have to disagree that there are "unwanted" horses out there. You can always find a horse a loving home, just like this precious blind one that Shiloh is taking in. To say a horse is "unwanted" is to say that nobody out there will ever want him/her, and that's not the case, ever. I am extremely involved in trying to put a stop to slaughter, rodeos and the production of Premarin "the drug given to women for menopause" Which is Pregnant Mare Urine. You can read a lot of information on my blog about these issues, it would be listed in my August blogs. My blog is: www.puttinghorsesfirst.blogspot.com I would encourage anyone to visit my blog and get some real important information, stuff not a lot of people know, even the people in the horse owning world. I feel in my heart that God is on our side with passing the bill H.R.6598 that has gone to vote yesterday Sept. 10th, the Lord knows we gave it our all in the fight, then he took over and made it come to pass. I'm just waiting to hear the words "bill H.R.6598 PASSED!! WE DID IT!!" I will be praising the Lord when I hear those words. My blog will have the Lords passage on how he feels about his horses, it's pretty intense. It will be at the very bottom of the blog, I welcome anyone to visit my blog and read it.
That horse is pretty. I think there is something that can be done with him. It just takes some one willing to work with him. Natural horseman ship might bring him around to be able to see human has his mate. He's not unwanted. Just find the right person to take him.
Oh how sad. That poor baby. I wouldn't have had the heart to leave him behind. I owuld have taken him home to to live out his life with my other rescues. Bless you Mickey for getting him.
I'm so glad that this Appy had a good ending. Yes, there is alot that you can do with a blind horse. I have 7 rescues and two of them are not perfect. I agree with the poster who said that the breeders should STOP breeding, especially after what I just read about the newborn foals being auctioned off in MN, not weanlings, not 6 mos. old but newborns with umbilical cords attached and the lies that were told about the horses to enrage people into believing that horse slaughter has been banned in this country (which it has not, at least not YET) and encourage them to sign against HR 6598 to end horse slaughter in this country. There are NO unwanted horses, just unlucky ones who end up in the slaughter pipeline. Certain breed associations and of course the Livestock Marketing Assn. and other meat type organizations are behind the lies and the propaganda in favor of horse slaughter. I'm glad to see that the truth comes to light especially in this story. Property rights comes into play also when horses are stolen out of people's paddocks, barns and taken to the auctions to be sold for slaughter.. where are their rights? If nothing else, when the end of life decision comes, humane euthasia administered by a vet is the only answer (or a well placed bullet) and burial, cremation, rendering or composting is the only option in my opinion. What do we do with the carcass is such a stupid question. And where did the landfill idea ever come from? I've had to face that decision myself and there was no major expense, nor was there any talk about a landfill or disposal problems. If people cannot afford to put them down, then they shouldn't own a horse in the first place.
I support the horse protection bills (HR 503, HR 6598 and S 311) in their entirety and I feel that everyone on this blog (except for the one post) does too. God bless you all for your compassion.
I noticed a comment by "anonymous" stating that she/he found out that there were foals with their umbilical cords still attached going to a slaughter house through a auction house in MN. Can you tell me where you go your information from? And what the name of the auction house is? I do believe you, but in order for me to take action on these people I need some information from you. Don't worry, I won't give your name out, because actually I don't know your name. Thank you if you could give me this info. My email address is: lmbella@hotmail.com
This blog was sent to me through myspace. thank you for posting it. I operate a horse rescue in Millbrook, NY. We currently have 32 horses. Te thing speople do to their animals disgusts me. Just yesterday I got a phone call, so a few volunteers and I went ot investigate. An elderly couple has 2 Arabian mares. they are sisters out of the same dam. They are 22 and 25. The elderly couple has owned them and their dam since they were born. (awww right?) Don't you wish. In 25 years, the horses were never broke, never had their halters removed, never knew the joy all of our loved horses know - they were just owned. They are currently not vaccinated, however, their hooves are trimmed. Their teeth need filing. When we asked howmuch turn out the hoses are used to - we were told ever since the deer broke the fences, the horses have been kept in - 2 ARABIANS locked in stalls?? The most appalling part of this whole situation: The stalls had fresh bedding, and the WHITE water buckets were IMMACULATE!!! Yet, the horses were skiddish and coulnd't be touched. How than, does an elderly couple kep those stalls clean? It appeared they knew we were coming and cleaned up - tell me how 2 horses with an inch of dust on them, and stalls a foot deep in cobwebs have WHITE water buckets sitting on the floor that are so clean I'd drink from them. Please visit my blog www.luckyorphans.blogpsot.com. Thanks for posting!!
Such a beautiful and precious horse...I thank this most compassionate person for going to rescue him!! What a VERY lucky guy he is now, to have a loving *forever* home...God bless this dear soul and his rescuer!! Thank you Juli for sharing their story..
I would not have been able to walk away from a horse in that situation. If I was there I would have found a way to take him home with me or have him euthanized on the spot. Anyone who could walk away from a suffering, neglected horse like that is compliant in that suffering & neglect. Shame on you all who had the opportunity to help this horse and did nothing.
"If you are not a part of the solution you are a part of the problem."
"And to think...we still have those who maintain that there's no such thing as an unwanted horse."
Horses have been abandoned at auction barns long before the slaughter bills were pushed some months ago. As this article states, plenty are still going to slaughter -- in fact more than in 2006 or 2007 pre-bill passing.
The point this story REALLY makes is that slaughter buyers DO NOT take the 'unwanted horse'. I've seen them leave many behind that the owner fully intended to sell to meat: lame, starved, blind, EPM, EPSM. What they want are fit, healthy, young, "prime grade A meat".
They do not buy only the ones that families and trainers don't take; they bid as much as they need so they can still make money on the animal regardless of whom else may be interested in the animal.
Could it not be that the kill-buyers at this particular auction are aware that IT IS ILLEGAL TO TRANSPORT A BLIND (OR CRIPPLED) HORSE TO SLAUGHTER?
Of course it happens all the time, but as with all people, kill-buyers exist on a continuum of law-abidingness, etc.
i have 2 blind horses 1 aqha 13 year old gelding some of the best bloodlines shown and done ranch work his owners were gona put him to sleep and i couldn't let that happened she happly gave him and delivered him he can see very very little out one eye the sweetest horse slightly hard to catch at first but once he has come to you and you put his halter on all his attention is on you i we have even ridden him he does great but if he hears me and some one else is ridding him he want do anything for them my sister will tell me to be quite, my other a 5 year draft mix mare went blind on me after having her for 4 years all of s sudden she stopped comming up to eat and would take forever to come up and lost a alot of weight my vet came out and said what i already knew she's blind, it took 2&1/2 hours to walk her from one pasture to the other which should've been a 4-5 minute walk, i cried so hard, it was really hard on her, i put her in with my blind gelding, now almost a year latter they are best friends she is totally blind but such a sweet horse. one day not long after i put her with him i heard her squeling i ran to go she what was wrong and she was kicking all she was worth i never laughed so hard the gelding was at the far side of the pasture away from her she was backing up and kicking out she thought he was back there funny but sad
Post a Comment
<< Home